Insulation resistance and dielectric strength are often treated as two ways of doing the same check. They are not. One measures how much the insulation resists a small DC voltage over time; the other proves the insulation survives a large AC voltage for a short time. A product can pass either one and fail the other.
What each test detects
| Insulation resistance | Dielectric strength | |
| Signal | DC, commonly 500 V | AC at mains frequency, occasionally DC |
| Duration | Reading after a defined electrification time, often 60 s | 1 min, or a shorter time at a higher voltage where the standard allows |
| Finds | Moisture, contamination, cracks, degraded material | Clearances that break down, thin walls, tracking paths |
| Failure mode | Reading below the limit | Breakdown, flashover, trip |
Why the IR reading falls with time
Applying DC to insulation charges it like a capacitor. The current starts high and decays; the resistance reading therefore rises during the test. That is why the standard specifies an electrification time. Reading at 5 s instead of 60 s can show half the true value on a capacitive product. Practical rules:
- Use the electrification time in the product standard, and keep it the same across a comparison series.
- Discharge the specimen after the test; a charged capacitor in a test fixture is a hazard and a source of the next wrong reading.
- For large machines, a polarisation index (ratio of the 10 min to the 1 min reading) is more informative than a single value.
Why humidity changes everything
Surface resistance depends on adsorbed water. A product that reads 500 MOhm in a dry room can read 5 MOhm after a humid night. Conditioning before the test is part of the test, not a preliminary. Record temperature and relative humidity with every result; a result without them cannot be compared with anything.
Setting the dielectric test voltage
The test voltage is set by the product standard, not by the laboratory. For a 250 V appliance, a common scheme tests basic insulation at 1000 V AC and reinforced insulation at 3000 V AC for one minute, with lower values allowed for routine production testing. Two points matter more than the number:
- Ramp, do not switch. A sudden application produces a transient that can break down a healthy insulation. Ramp over a few seconds and hold.
- Trip current must be appropriate. A setting high enough to avoid nuisance trips on capacitance may be too high to catch a real breakdown on a small product. Where the standard allows, use the lowest setting that is stable.
The test that damages the product
A hipot test applies stress. Repeating it many times shortens life, and testing a product that has already passed at a higher voltage than specified proves nothing except that the insulation survived the test. Production routines should use the reduced voltage and time allowed by the standard, not the type-test values.
Practical sequence for a bench check
- Stabilise the product at the specified temperature and humidity.
- Measure IR at the specified voltage, wait the full electrification time, record the value and the conditions.
- Discharge, then apply the dielectric voltage with a controlled ramp.
- Hold for the specified time, watch for breakdown or excessive leakage, then ramp down.
- Repeat the IR check after the dielectric test; a large drop indicates damage caused by the test itself.
Instruments for both checks are grouped in the electrical safety test range; the withstand voltage testers page lists ramp and trip-current options.
