Two laboratories testing the same material to the same temperature can reach different results, and the difference is often in a part that costs less than the report: the glow-wire loop. IEC 60695-2-10 fixes the temperature, the application time and the loop geometry; it does not fix the condition of the loop in your laboratory. That is what this article is about.
The loop is consumed by the test. It oxidises, it deforms, it picks up material from specimens, and its thermocouple works loose. All four change the result, and none of them is visible in a report that records only the set temperature.
What the apparatus is supposed to deliver
| Tip form | Nickel-chromium loop, tip nominally 4 mm across, formed so the contact face is a defined surface |
| Temperature sensing | Thermocouple in the tip, not in the power supply or the carriage |
| Stabilisation | At least 60 s at the set temperature before the first application |
| Applied force | 1 N against the specimen, delivered by the carriage, not by hand |
| Application time | 30 s for a flammability index determination |
Why a deformed loop gives a wrong answer
The heat path from loop to specimen is contact conduction plus radiation. A loop that has been straightened, re-ground or squeezed changes the contact area, and contact area is the dominant term at the moment of touch. Three specific deformations and their effects:
- Flattened tip. Contact area increases, heat transfer improves, and the specimen sees a hotter effective source. A marginal pass becomes a fail, which at least errs on the safe side.
- Spread loop. The two legs separate, the contact area splits into two small points, and the effective heat input drops. A fail becomes a pass, which is the dangerous direction.
- Kinked leg. The loop no longer sits square to the specimen, one leg touches first, and the application is asymmetric. Results scatter without an obvious cause.
The check is a 10x magnifier and a go/no-go slot. If the tip does not pass the slot, or the two legs are not parallel within a visible tolerance, replace the loop. Straightening a loop by hand is not a repair.
The thermocouple seat is the hidden variable
The thermocouple must be in intimate contact with the tip, inside the loop, at the point that contacts the specimen. Three failure modes, all common:
- Loose in the bore. The junction sits a fraction of a millimetre back from the tip and reads low. The controller drives the loop hotter to reach set point, so the specimen is tested above the intended temperature.
- Contaminated junction. Oxide or specimen residue on the junction damps the response and adds a slow offset.
- Wrong bead size. A large bead has a slow response and a thermal gradient across it. A 0.5 mm bead responds within a second; a 1.5 mm bead takes several seconds and reads a running average.
A simple verification: set 960 degrees C, let it stabilise, then read the tip with a calibrated contact pyrometer or a second thermocouple pressed against the loop. A difference of more than about 10 K between the controller and the independent reading means the seat or the bead is wrong.
Drift during application and why it matters
When the loop touches a cold specimen, the tip temperature falls. The controller restores it, but not instantly. A drop of 15 K at the moment of contact is enough to move a marginal result, because the material's behaviour around its ignition threshold is steep.
Two practices reduce the problem:
- Record the tip temperature at 5 s into the application, not only at the set point. Many modern instruments log it; if yours does not, a second thermocouple and a data logger will.
- Keep the specimen at room temperature and at a consistent moisture content. A damp specimen cools the tip more and produces more steam, which affects flaming behaviour independently of the material.
The four observations, not one
After the loop is withdrawn, four things are recorded. Reporting only the first is the most common reporting deficiency:
- Time to extinguish after withdrawal.
- Whether the underlying tissue paper ignites. A falling flaming droplet is a fail even when the specimen self-extinguishes, and this is the finding most often missed.
- Depth of penetration, measured from the original surface.
- Post-test condition: hole, char, cracking, and whether the part still performs its function.
Maintenance schedule that prevents surprises
- Before each session: inspect the loop, check the force with a balance, confirm the tissue paper is fresh and positioned at the specified distance below the specimen.
- Weekly: verify tip temperature independently, check the carriage for free movement, clean the loop bore.
- Monthly: measure applied force at the specimen plane, not at the carriage, and record it.
- On every loop change: re-verify temperature and force, and record the loop identification in the report.
The point of the schedule is comparability. A result is only meaningful against a result from the same apparatus in the same condition, and the loop is the part of the apparatus that changes fastest.
The flammability testing range includes glow-wire apparatus, replacement loops and force verification jigs; the catalogue home indexes the needle-flame and ball-pressure equipment used in the same series of tests.
