Two testers, one product, one standard, and a choice that changes what the test proves. An AC dielectric test and a DC dielectric test at the equivalent voltage stress the insulation differently, fail different defects, and are not interchangeable even when the arithmetic says they are.
The arithmetic is the easy part: the peak of a sine wave is 1.414 times its RMS value, so a 1,500 V AC test and a 2,121 V DC test reach the same peak. Everything after that is engineering.
The comparison that matters
| Aspect | AC test | DC test |
| Voltage for the same peak | 1,500 V RMS | 2,121 V DC |
| Stress on a void | Alternating, so partial discharge repeats every half cycle | Constant, so a void may not discharge at all |
| Leakage measured | Mostly capacitive current, plus resistive | Resistive only |
| Damage on failure | Usually self-clearing at the zero crossing | Sustained, and can carbonise a path |
| Suitable for | Complete equipment, wound components | Cables, capacitors, equipment with large capacitance |
| Test duration | Usually 1 minute | 1 minute, sometimes longer for stabilisation |
The first row is why AC is the reference method for equipment. A void inside solid insulation is a small gas pocket; under AC it is stressed twice per cycle and discharges, which is what gradually damages it and what the test is meant to detect. Under DC the field is static and the void may sit below its inception voltage for the whole test.
The leakage current is a different quantity
In an AC test, the current through the insulation is dominated by capacitance: at 50 Hz, a few nanofarads at 1,500 V is a milliamp of reactive current before any defect exists. The trip limit has to be set above that, which is why AC hipot testers are often set to 5 mA or 10 mA and why a 2 mA defect can hide inside normal capacitive current.
In a DC test there is no steady capacitive current after charging, so the measured leakage is resistive and much smaller. A limit of a few microamps becomes possible, and a defect that would be invisible under AC stands out. The price is that the test no longer exercises the void.
Choosing between them
- Routine production test on complete equipment: AC, because it is the method the standard is written around and it is self-limiting on failure.
- Equipment with large capacitance: DC, because the AC charging current would exceed the trip limit and the tester would never reach the test voltage.
- After a repair or a field return: whichever the original type test used, so the results are comparable.
- When the standard gives a DC alternative: use the factor it states, which is usually the square root of two but not always.
The traps
A DC test charges the insulation like a capacitor, and the specimen stays charged after the tester is switched off. The discharge resistor in the tester may take minutes on a large specimen, and a person who touches a terminal in that window gets a shock from stored energy rather than from the supply. Always confirm the voltage has fallen to zero before handling.
Ramp rate matters too: a fast ramp produces a charging current that trips the tester on a good product. A few hundred volts per second, with a dwell at the test voltage, gives a stable reading. A hipot tester with separate AC and DC modes and an adjustable ramp is the practical choice, and the site index lists the models by output voltage and trip range.
Standards referenced: IEC 61010-1; IEC 60243-1.
